What are potential benefit and risk for Somalia from Somaliland and Ethiopia deal

Introduction

The Somaliland-Ethiopia deal presents both potential benefits and risks for Somalia:

Potential Benefits

Diplomatic Engagement

The deal has prompted increased diplomatic activity, potentially leading to more constructive dialogue between Somalia and Ethiopia. This is evidenced by the recent agreement to hold “technical talks” mediated by Turkey, which could help resolve long-standing issues.

Economic Opportunities

The negotiations may lead to “mutually advantageous commercial arrangements” that could benefit Somalia economically, particularly if Ethiopia gains sea access under Somali sovereignty.

Regional Stability

The diplomatic efforts to resolve the dispute could contribute to greater stability in the Horn of Africa, which is crucial for Somalia’s long-term development and security.

Potential Risks

Territorial Integrity

The deal poses a significant threat to Somalia’s territorial integrity, as it could lead to the recognition of Somaliland as an independent state, which Somalia vehemently opposes.

Regional Tensions

The agreement has heightened tensions in the region, potentially destabilizing Somalia’s relationships with neighboring countries and complicating its efforts to combat al-Shabaab.

Military Concern

There are fears that the deal could lead to an increased Ethiopian military presence near Somalia’s borders, potentially threatening Somalia’s security.

Diplomatic Isolation

If Ethiopia proceeds with recognizing Somaliland, it could encourage other countries to follow suit, potentially isolating Somalia diplomatically.

Internal Divisions

The deal has sparked protests within Somalia and could exacerbate internal divisions, particularly between the central government and regions seeking greater autonomy.

Economic Competition

The development of Ethiopian-controlled ports in Somaliland could compete with Somalia’s existing ports, potentially impacting its economic interests.

Conclusion

While the situation remains fluid, the recent Turkey-mediated talks suggest a potential path towards de-escalation and compromise. However, Somalia will need to navigate these complex dynamics carefully to protect its interests while seeking opportunities for regional cooperation and development.