Foreign Affairs Forum

View Original

Future of Kurds is Blakey in Syria, Turkey and Iraq

Introduction

The future of Kurds in Syria, Turkey, and Iraq appears increasingly uncertain and fraught with challenges. Recent developments in the region have significantly altered the political landscape, potentially impacting Kurdish autonomy and aspirations across these countries.

The estimated total number of Kurds in Turkey, Iraq, and Syria is approximately 33.15 million.

Here’s the breakdown by country:

Turkey: Approximately 14-15 million Kurds (18-20% of Turkey’s population)

Iraq: Around 5.45 - 8 million Kurds (estimate)

Syria: Between 2-2.5 million Kurds

Syria: A Precarious Position

In Syria, the Kurdish-led Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria (AANES) faces multiple threats:

Turkish Pressure

Turkey views the Syrian Kurdish forces, particularly the YPG (People’s Protection Units), as an extension of the PKK (Kurdistan Workers’ Party), which it considers a terrorist organization. This has led to ongoing military operations and the threat of a major ground offensive against Kurdish-controlled areas in northern Syria.

Regime Change

The recent fall of the Assad regime has created a power vacuum, with Turkish-backed forces and Islamist groups like Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) gaining ground. This shift threatens Kurdish control over certain areas and raises questions about the future of their autonomous region.

Uncertain International Support

With the defeat of ISIS, Western support for Syrian Kurds has waned. The potential withdrawal of U.S. troops could leave the Kurds vulnerable to attacks from various factions.

Turkey: Domestic Politics and Regional Ambitions

Turkey’s approach to its Kurdish population and neighboring Kurdish regions remains complex:

Political Outreach

Recent gestures by Turkish President Erdogan and his allies suggest a potential shift in Kurdish policy, possibly aimed at securing Kurdish support for constitutional changes.

Military Operations

Despite political overtures, Turkey continues to conduct military operations against Kurdish forces in Syria and Iraq, citing security concerns.

PKK Factor

The Turkish government’s stance on the PKK remains a critical factor in its Kurdish policy, both domestically and regionally.

Iraq: Relative Stability Under Threat

The Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) in Iraq enjoys a more established autonomous status but faces its own challenges:

Economic Prosperity

The KRG has achieved relative economic success and stability compared to other Kurdish regions.

External Threats

Both Turkey and Iran have conducted military operations in Iraqi Kurdistan, targeting PKK-affiliated groups.

Internal Divisions

Cooperation among Kurdish factions across different countries remains crucial for their collective strength.

Uncertain Future

The future of Kurds in these countries remains uncertain due to several factors:

Shifting Alliances

The rapidly changing political landscape in Syria could lead to new alliances or conflicts affecting Kurdish autonomy.

International Involvement

The roles of major powers like the U.S., Russia, and regional actors will significantly influence Kurdish fortunes.

Economic Challenges

While Iraqi Kurdistan has achieved relative prosperity, Syrian Kurdish regions face severe economic difficulties.

Political Negotiations

The ability of Kurdish leaders to negotiate with various state and non-state actors will be crucial in securing their rights and autonomy.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while Kurds in Iraq have achieved a degree of stability and autonomy, their counterparts in Syria face an increasingly precarious situation.

In Turkey, the government’s approach remains ambivalent, mixing political outreach with military operations.

The coming years will be critical in determining whether Kurds can maintain and expand their autonomy or face further marginalization in the complex geopolitical landscape of the Middle East.