Foreign Affairs Forum

View Original

How do non-persistent land mines differ from traditional ones

Introduction

Non-persistent land mines differ from traditional land mines in several key aspects:

Design and Function

Self-Destruction Mechanism:

Non-persistent land mines are designed with a self-destruction feature that causes them to detonate automatically after a predetermined period, typically within 30 days or less after emplacement.

Self-Deactivation Feature:

These mines also possess a backup self-deactivation feature, which renders the mine inert if the self-destruction mechanism fails to function.

Lifespan and Hazard Duration

Limited Active Period:

Non-persistent mines are intended to remain active for a shorter duration compared to traditional mines, which can remain dangerous indefinitely.

Reduced Long-Term Risk:

The self-destruction and self-deactivation features aim to minimize the long-term hazard to civilians and non-combatants after conflicts end.

Deployment Methods

Remote Delivery:

Non-persistent mines can often be scattered or remotely delivered by aircraft, artillery, or ground dispensers, allowing for rapid deployment over wide areas.

Controversy and Limitations

Reliability Concerns:

Despite their “smart” features, non-persistent mines are not foolproof. The Government Accountability Office for that “smart mines” deployed in the Gulf War failed at a rate 150 times higher than reported by the Department of Defense.

Explosive Remnants:

While the trigger mechanisms may deactivate, the explosive materials in non-persistent mines can remain lethal, maintaining their indiscriminate nature and potential to harm civilians.

Clearance Challenges:

The clearance of non-persistent mines can still be dangerous, time-consuming, and costly for deminers, as mines that have failed to self-destruct must be treated as live.

Conclusion

It’s important to note that despite these differences, non-persistent land mines still pose significant risks to civilian populations and remain controversial in their use and effectiveness in reducing unintended harm.